Research Progress in Novel In-situ Integrative Photovoltaic-storage Tandem Cells

doi:10.15541/jim20190342

Abstract

Abstract:

As smart electronic products are increasingly applied in our daily life, there is not only an increasing demand for high-performance photovoltaic power generation devices, but also strong need for in-situ energy storage functions in these devices. The integration of energy generating components and energy storage components into one device has become an attractive challenging technology. The basic idea is that by integration design and engineering the assembly of the photoelectric conversion layer and the energy storage layer into one in-situ energy conversion and storage system could not only offer multiple functions, such as self-powered ability, weak light buffer and portability, but reduce sunlight fluctuation effect on energy output. This review summarizes the research progress in novel in-situ integrative photovoltaic-storage tandem cells, classified by silicon solar cell, sensitized solar cell and perovskite solar cell. Evaluation of methodology, operational principle, construction feature, and performance parameter are also discussed and critically reviewed, and the further development of in-situ integrative photovoltaic-storage tandem cell is also prospected.

Key words: silicon solar cell, sensitized solar cell, perovskite solar cell, energy storage, photovoltaic-storage, in-situ integration, review

CLC Number:

TQ174

YU Shouwu, ZHAO Zewen, ZHAO Jinjin, XIAO Shujuan, SHI Yan, GAO Cunfa, SU Xiao, HU Yuxiang, ZHAO Zhisheng, WANG Jie, WANG Lianzhou. Research Progress in Novel In-situ Integrative Photovoltaic-storage Tandem Cells[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2020, 35(6): 623-632.

Figures/Tables 7

References 77

[1]	CELIK I, PHILLIPS A B, SONG Z N , et al. Environmental analysis of perovskites and other relevant solar cell technologies in a tandem configuration. Energy & Environmental Science, 2017,10(9):1874-1884.
[2]	SHUKLA R, SUMATHY K, ERICKSON P , et al. Recent advances in the solar water heating systems: a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2013,19:173-190. DOI URL
[3]	HEDLEY G J, RUSECKAS A, SAMUEL I D W. Light harvesting for organic photovoltaics. Chemical Reviews, 2016,117(2):796-837.
[4]	IONESCU C, BARACU T, VLAD G E , et al. The historical evolution of the energy efficient buildings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2015,49:243-253. DOI URL
[5]	SHARMA S, JAIN K K, SHARMA A . Solar cells: in research and applications—a review. Materials Sciences and Applications, 2015,6(12):1145. DOI URL
[6]	RAN J R, ZHANG J, YU J G , et al. Earth-abundant cocatalysts for semiconductor-based photocatalytic water splitting. Chemical Society Reviews, 2014,43(22):7787-7812. DOI URL
[7]	YUAN Y L, LU Y D, JIA B E , et al. Integrated system of solar cells with hierarchical NiCo₂O₄ battery-supercapacitor hybrid devices for self-driving light-emitting diodes. Nano-Micro Letters, 2019,11(1):42. DOI URL
[8]	YUAN Y L, WU Y H, ZHANG T , et al. Integration of solar cells with hierarchical CoS_x nanonets hybrid supercapacitors for self-powered photodetection systems. Journal of Power Sources, 2018,404:118-125.
[9]	SELVAM S, BALAMURALITHARAN B, KARTHICK S N , et al. Novel high-temperature supercapacitor combined dye sensitized solar cell from a sulfated β-cyclodextrin/PVP/MnCO₃ composite. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2015,3(19):10225-10232.
[10]	HASSANALIERAGH M, SOYATA T, NADEAU A , et al. UR-SolarCap: an open source intelligent auto-wakeup solar energy harvesting system for supercapacitor-based energy buffering. IEEE Access, 2016,4:542-557.
[11]	YANG Z B, DENG J, SUN H , et al. Self-powered energy fiber: energy conversion in the sheath and storage in the core. Advanced Materials, 2014,26(41):7038-7042.
[12]	MIYASAKA T, MURAKAMI T N . The photocapacitor: an efficient self-charging capacitor for direct storage of solar energy. Applied Physics Letters, 2004,85(17):3932-3934.
[13]	LIU Z Y, ZHONG Y, SUN B , et al. Novel integration of perovskite solar cell and supercapacitor based on carbon electrode for hybridizing energy conversion and storage. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2017,9(27):22361-22368. DOI URL
[14]	GURUNG A, QIAO Q Q . Solar charging batteries: advances, challenges, and opportunities. Joule, 2018,2(7):1217-1230.
[15]	SCHMIDT D, HAGER M D, SCHUBERT U S . Photo-rechargeable electric energy storage systems. Advanced Energy Materials, 2016,6(1):1500369. DOI URL
[16]	LECHENE B P, CLERC R, ARIAS A C . Theoretical analysis and characterization of the energy conversion and storage efficiency of photo-supercapacitors. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 2017,172:202-212. DOI URL
[17]	LIU R Y, LIU Y Q, ZOU H Y , et al. Integrated solar capacitors for energy conversion and storage. Nano Research, 2017,10(5):1545-1559.
[18]	FU Y P, WU H W, YE S Y , et al. Integrated power fiber for energy conversion and storage. Energy & Environmental Science, 2013,6(3):805-812.
[19]	LIU H H, LI M P, KANER R B , et al. Monolithically integrated self-charging power pack consisting of a silicon nanowire array/ conductive polymer hybrid solar cell and a laser-scribed graphene supercapacitor. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2018,10(18):15609-15615.
[20]	CHAPIN D M, FULLER C S, PEARSON G L . A new silicon p-n junction photocell for converting solar radiation into electrical power. Journal of Applied Physics, 1954,25(5):676-677.
[21]	ALI H, KOUL S, GREGORY G , et al. In situ transmission electron microscopy study of molybdenum oxide contacts for silicon solar cells. Physica Status Solidi (a), 2019,216(7):1800998.
[22]	CHAN C E, WENHAM S R, HALLAM B J , et al. Monolithically integrated solar cell system. U.S., 10/211, 354. 2019-2-19.
[23]	NOGAY G, SAHLI F, WERNER J , et al. 25.1%-efficient monolithic perovskite/silicon tandem solar cell based on a p-type monocrystalline textured silicon wafer and high-temperature passivating contacts. ACS Energy Letters, 2019,4(4):844-845. DOI URL
[24]	ZHAO X W, WU H S, YANG L S , et al. High efficiency CNT-Si heterojunction solar cells by dry gas doping. Carbon, 2019,147:164-171. DOI URL
[25]	WU X W, LI J Y, TAN Y . Technology of preparing diamond wire cut multicrystalline silicon wafer texture surface. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2017,32(9):985-990. DOI URL
[26]	LIU X J, JIA L J, FAN G P , et al. Au nanoparticle enhanced thin-film silicon solar cells. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 2016,147:225-234. DOI URL
[27]	REN X D, ZI W, MA Q , et al. Topology and texture controlled ZnO thin film electrodeposition for superior solar cell efficiency. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 2015,134:54-59. DOI URL
[28]	LIU X J, ZI W, LIU S Z. p-Layer bandgap engineering for high efficiency thin film silicon solar cells. Materials Science in Semiconductor Processing, 2015,39:192-199.
[29]	LIU R Y, WANG J, SUN T , et al. Silicon nanowire/polymer hybrid solar cell-supercapacitor: a self-charging power unit with a total efficiency of 10.5%. Nano Letters, 2017,17(7):4240-4247.
[30]	THEKKEKARA L V, JIA B H, ZHANG Y , et al. On-chip energy storage integrated with solar cells using a laser scribed graphene oxide film. Applied Physics Letters, 2015,107(3):031105.
[31]	UM H D, CHOI K H, HWANG I , et al. Monolithically integrated, photo-rechargeable portable power sources based on miniaturized Si solar cells and printed solid-state lithium-ion batteries. Energy & Environmental Science, 2017,10(4):931-940.
[32]	O'REGAN B, GRÄTZEL M. A low-cost, high-efficiency solar cell based on dye-sensitized colloidal TiO₂ films. Nature, 1991,353(6346):737.
[33]	YUN S, FREITAS J N, NOGUEIRA A F , et al. Dye-sensitized solar cells employing polymers. Progress in Polymer Science, 2016,59:1-40. DOI URL
[34]	SU’AIT M S, RAHMAN M Y A, AHMAD A . Review on polymer electrolyte in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs). Solar Energy, 2015,115:452-470.
[35]	MAHMOOD A . Recent research progress on quasi-solid-state electrolytes for dye-sensitized solar cells. Journal of Energy Chemistry, 2015,24(6):686-692.
[36]	MENG X D, YIN M, SHU T , et al. Research progress on counter electrodes of quantum dot-sensitized solar cells. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2018,33(5):483-493.
[37]	MURAKAMI T N, KAWASHIMA N, MIYASAKA T . A high- voltage dye-sensitized photocapacitor of a three-electrode system. Chemical Communications, 2005(26):3346-3348.
[38]	SAITO Y, OGAWA A, UCHIDA S , et al. Energy-storable dye-sensitized solar cells with interdigitated nafion/polypyrrole-Pt comb-like electrodes. Chemistry Letters, 2010,39(5):488-489.
[39]	YANG Z B, LI L, LUO Y F , et al. An integrated device for both photoelectric conversion and energy storage based on free-standing and aligned carbon nanotube film. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2013,1(3):954-958. DOI URL
[40]	ZHANG X, HUANG X Z, LI C S , et al. Dye-sensitized solar cell with energy storage function through PVDF/ZnO nanocomposite counter electrode. Advanced Materials, 2013,25(30):4093-4096.
[41]	COHN A P, ERWIN W R, SHARE K , et al. All silicon electrode photocapacitor for integrated energy storage and conversion. Nano Letters, 2015,15(4):2727-2731. DOI URL
[42]	SKUNIK-NUCKOWSKA M, GRZEJSZCZYK K, KULESZ P J , et al. Integration of solid-state dye-sensitized solar cell with metal oxide charge storage material into photoelectrochemical capacitor. Journal of Power Sources, 2013,234:91-99.
[43]	SCALIA A, BELLA F, LAMBERTI A , et al. A flexible and portable powerpack by solid-state supercapacitor and dye-sensitized solar cell integration. Journal of Power Sources, 2017,359:311-321.
[44]	CHEN T, QIU L B, YANG Z L , et al. An integrated “energy wire” for both photoelectric conversion and energy storage. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2012,51(48):11977-11980. DOI URL
[45]	CHEN X L, SUN H, YANG Z B , et al. A novel “energy fiber” by coaxially integrating dye-sensitized solar cell and electrochemical capacitor. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2014,2(6):1897-1902. DOI URL
[46]	WEN Z, YEH M H, GUO H Y , et al. Self-powered textile for wearable electronics by hybridizing fiber-shaped nanogenerators, solar cells, and supercapacitors. Science Advances, 2016,2(10):e1600097. DOI URL
[47]	Best Research-Cell Efficiency Chart(NREL). https://www.nrel. gov/pv/cell-efficiency.html.
[48]	SHI C L, DONG H, ZHU R , et al. An “all-in-one” mesh-typed integrated energy unit for both photoelectric conversion and energy storage in uniform electrochemical system. Nano Energy, 2015,13:670-678.
[49]	GUO W X, XUE X Y, WANG S H , et al. An integrated power pack of dye-sensitized solar cell and Li battery based on double-sided TiO₂ nanotube arrays. Nano Letters, 2012,12(5):2520-2523.
[50]	CHEN H W, HSU C Y, CHEN J G , et al. Plastic dye-sensitized photo-supercapacitor using electrophoretic deposition and compression methods. Journal of Power Sources, 2010,195(18):6225-6231. DOI URL
[51]	HSU C Y, CHEN H W, LEE K M , et al. A dye-sensitized photo-supercapacitor based on PProDOT-Et₂ thick films. Journal of Power Sources, 2010,195(18):6232-6238. DOI URL
[52]	XU J, WU H, LU L F , et al. Integrated photo-supercapacitor based on bi-polar TiO₂ nanotube arrays with selective one-side plasma‐assisted hydrogenation. Advanced Functional Materials, 2014,24(13):1840-1846. DOI URL
[53]	LIU P, CAO Y L, LI G R , et al. A solar rechargeable flow battery based on photoregeneration of two soluble redox couples. ChemSusChem, 2013,6(5):802-806. DOI URL
[54]	YAN N F, LI G R, GAO X P . Electroactive organic compounds as anode-active materials for solar rechargeable redox flow battery in dual-phase electrolytes. Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 2014,161(5):A736-A741. DOI URL
[55]	KAGAN C R, MITZI D B, DIMITRAKOPOULOS C D . Organic- inorganic hybrid materials as semiconducting channels in thin-film field-effect transistors. Science, 1999,286(5441):945-947. DOI URL
[56]	MITZI D B, FEILD C A, HARRISON W T A, et al. Conducting tin halides with a layered organic-based perovskite structure. Nature, 1994,369(6480):467. DOI URL
[57]	KOJIAMA A, TESHIMA K, SHIRAI Y , et al. Organometal halide perovskites as visible-light sensitizers for photovoltaic cells. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 2009,131(17):6050-6051. DOI URL
[58]	CHU Z Y, LI G L, JIANG Z H , et al. Recent progress in high-quality perovskite CH₃NH₃PbI₃ single crystal. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2018,33(10):1035-1045. DOI URL
[59]	JIANG Q, CHU Z M, WANG P Y , et al. Planar-structure perovskite solar cells with efficiency beyond 21%. Advanced Materials, 2017,29(46):1703852. DOI URL
[60]	JIANG Q, ZHANG L Q, WANG H L , et al. Enhanced electron extraction using SnO₂ for high-efficiency planar-structure HC(NH₂)₂PbI₃-based perovskite solar cells. Nature Energy, 2017,2(1):16177. DOI URL
[61]	XIONG L B, GUO Y X, WEN J , et al. Review on the application of SnO₂ in perovskite solar cells. Advanced Functional Materials, 2018,28(35):1802757. DOI URL
[62]	DJURIŠIĆ A B, LIU F Z, TAM H W , et al. Perovskite solar cells-an overview of critical issues. Progress in Quantum Electronics, 2017,53:1-37. DOI URL
[63]	HUANG J, XIANG S H, YU J S , et al. Highly efficient prismatic perovskite solar cells. Energy & Environmental Science, 2019,12(3):929-937. DOI URL
[64]	JUNG E H, JEON N J, PARK E Y , et al. Efficient, stable and scalable perovskite solar cells using poly (3-hexylthiophene). Nature, 2019,567(7749):511. DOI URL
[65]	MUNDHAAS N, YU Z J, BUSH K A , et al. Series resistance measurements of perovskite solar cells using J_sc-V_oc measurements. Solar RRL, 2019,3(4):1800378. DOI URL
[66]	SCHMAGER R, GOMARD G, RICHARDS B S , et al. Nanophotonic perovskite layers for enhanced current generation and mitigation of lead in perovskite solar cells. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 2019,192:65-71. DOI URL
[67]	SHIN S S, SUK J H, KANG B J , et al. Energy-level engineering of the electron transporting layer for improving open-circuit voltage in dye and perovskite-based solar cells. Energy & Environmental Science, 2019,12(3):958-964.
[68]	XIAO Y Q, WANG C L, KONDAMAREDDY K K , et al. Enhancing the performance of hole-conductor free carbon-based perovskite solar cells through rutile-phase passivation of anatase TiO₂ scaffold. Journal of Power Sources, 2019,422:138-144. DOI URL
[69]	YANG D B, SANO T S, YAGUCHI Y , et al. Achieving 20% efficiency for low‐temperature‐processed inverted perovskite solar cells. Advanced Functional Materials, 2019,29(12):1807556. DOI URL
[70]	WANG F Y, ZHANG Y H, YANG M F , et al. Exploring low-temperature processed a-WO_x/SnO₂ hybrid electron transporting layer for perovskite solar cells with efficiency >20.5%. Nano Energy, 2019,63:103825 DOI URL
[71]	XU X B, LI S H, ZHANG H , et al. A power pack based on organometallic perovskite solar cell and supercapacitor. ACS Nano, 2015,9(2):1782-1787. DOI URL
[72]	LIANG J, ZHU G Y, LU Z P , et al. Integrated perovskite solar capacitors with high energy conversion efficiency and fast photo- charging rate. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2017,6(5):2047-2052. DOI URL
[73]	KIM J, LEE S M, HWANG Y H , et al. A highly efficient self-power pack system integrating supercapacitors and photovoltaics with an area-saving monolithic architecture. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2017,5(5):1906-1912. DOI URL
[74]	LIU R H, LIU C H, FAN S S . A photocapacitor based on organometal halide perovskite and PANI/CNT composites integrated using a CNT bridge. Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2017,5(44):23078-23084. DOI URL
[75]	LI C, ISLAM M M, MOORE J L , et al. Wearable energy-smart ribbons for synchronous energy harvest and storage. Nature Communications, 2016,7:13319. DOI URL
[76]	JIA C M, ZHAO X Y, LAI Y H , et al. Highly flexible, robust, stable and high efficiency perovskite solar cells enabled by van der Waals epitaxy on mica substrate. Nano Energy, 2019,60:476-484. DOI URL
[77]	HU Y X, BAI Y, LUO B , et al. A portable and efficient solar-rechargeable battery with ultrafast photo-charge/discharge rate. Advanced Energy Materials, 2019,9(28):1900872. DOI URL

Solar cell type	Device construction	η_overall*/%	η_solar*/%	η_storage*/%	Ref.
	PEDOT:PSS/n-Si/Ti/PE/(PVA/H₃PO₄)/PE/Ti	10.50	13.39	78.42	[29]
SiSC-SPC	Glass/c-Si/Insulation layer/Graphene oxides/ Electrolyte/Substrate	9.72	15.69	62.00	[30]
	PEDOT:PSS/Si/Au/Graphene/Separator/Graphene/PET	2.92	12.37	23.61	[19]
SiSC-LIB	c-Si/Al/SiO₂/Al/Li₄Ti₅O₁₂/Soild electrolyte/LiCoO₂/ Al/Li₄Ti₅O₁₂/Solid electrolyte/LiCoO₂/Al	7.61	15.80	48.16	[31]

Solar cell type	Device construction	η_overall*/%	η_solar*/%	η_storage*/%	Ref.
	PEDOT:PSS/n-Si/Ti/PE/(PVA/H₃PO₄)/PE/Ti	10.50	13.39	78.42	[29]
SiSC-SPC	Glass/c-Si/Insulation layer/Graphene oxides/ Electrolyte/Substrate	9.72	15.69	62.00	[30]
	PEDOT:PSS/Si/Au/Graphene/Separator/Graphene/PET	2.92	12.37	23.61	[19]
SiSC-LIB	c-Si/Al/SiO₂/Al/Li₄Ti₅O₁₂/Soild electrolyte/LiCoO₂/ Al/Li₄Ti₅O₁₂/Solid electrolyte/LiCoO₂/Al	7.61	15.80	48.16	[31]

Solar cell type	Device construction	η_overall*/%	η_solar*/%	η_storage*/%	Ref.
DSSC-SPC	FTO/TiO₂@dye/LiI/Carbon layer/Porous separator/C/Pt	-	-	59.00	[12]
	FTO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/Carbon/Separator/Electrolyte/C/Pt	-	-	42.00	[37]
	TCO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^- gel/MWCNT /PVA-H₃PO₄/MWCNT	5.12	6.10	84.00	[39]
	FTO/TiO₂@N719/ I^-/I₃^- /Zn NWs@PVDF @Au@Pt/FTO	3.70	-	-	[40]
	Glass/FTO/TiO₂@dye/ I^-/I₃^-/Si/Ionic polymer/Si wafer	2.10	2.63	80.00	[41]
	FTO/TiO₂-D365dye/P3HT/Ag/RuO_x(OH)_y/Nafion membrane/ RuO_x(OH)_y/FTO	0.80	0.91	88.00	[42]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/ I^-/I₃^-/Pt/Parafilm/C/PVDF/ SS	1.46	2.03	71.56	[43]
	CNT fiber@CNTs/ Ti wire/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/CNT fiber	1.50	6.10	84.00	[44]
	Ti wire/TiO₂@N719/Eutectic melts/CNTs-Ti wire/ TiO₂ /PVA-H₃PO₄/CNT	2.07	2.73	75.70	[45]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/MWCNT/Separator/MWCNT/PVA-H₃PO₄/MWCNT	1.83	6.47	28.30	[11]
	Ti Fiber@TiO₂@dye/ I^-/I₃^-/Stainless steel(ss)@PANi-SS@Space wire/H₂SO₄/ss@PANi	2.12	4.56	46.00	[18]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Carbon fiber(CF)/EVA/Cu-CF@RuO₂?xH₂O/H₃PO₄/PVA/CF@RuO₂?xH₂O/EVA/Cu/PDMS	-	5.64	-	[46]
QDSSC-SPC	Glass/FTO/TiO₂@CdS/CdSe/S^2-/S/Cfiber@Cu₂S/C/Electrolyte/C		1.8		[48]
DSSC-LIB	Pt/Electrolyte/TNTs@N719/Ti/TNTs/Membrane/LiCoO₂/Al	0.82	-	-	[49]
	PEN/ITO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/PEDOT/LiClO₄/PEDOT/Pt	-	4.37	-	[50]
	FTO/TiO₂@N3/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/PProDOT-Et₂/LiClO₄/PProDOT-Et₂/Pt	0.60	0.75	80.00	[51]
	FTO/Pt/ I^-/I₃^-/TiO₂nanotube (ATO)@N749/Ti/ ATO/Separator/Li₂SO₄/ATO/Ti/FTO	1.64	3.18	51.60	[52]
	FTO/TiO₂@bis-EDOT dye/PEDOT/C/LiClO₄/electrolyte/ppy/FTO	0.10	-	-	[53]

Solar cell type	Device construction	η_overall*/%	η_solar*/%	η_storage*/%	Ref.
DSSC-SPC	FTO/TiO₂@dye/LiI/Carbon layer/Porous separator/C/Pt	-	-	59.00	[12]
	FTO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/Carbon/Separator/Electrolyte/C/Pt	-	-	42.00	[37]
	TCO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^- gel/MWCNT /PVA-H₃PO₄/MWCNT	5.12	6.10	84.00	[39]
	FTO/TiO₂@N719/ I^-/I₃^- /Zn NWs@PVDF @Au@Pt/FTO	3.70	-	-	[40]
	Glass/FTO/TiO₂@dye/ I^-/I₃^-/Si/Ionic polymer/Si wafer	2.10	2.63	80.00	[41]
	FTO/TiO₂-D365dye/P3HT/Ag/RuO_x(OH)_y/Nafion membrane/ RuO_x(OH)_y/FTO	0.80	0.91	88.00	[42]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/ I^-/I₃^-/Pt/Parafilm/C/PVDF/ SS	1.46	2.03	71.56	[43]
	CNT fiber@CNTs/ Ti wire/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/CNT fiber	1.50	6.10	84.00	[44]
	Ti wire/TiO₂@N719/Eutectic melts/CNTs-Ti wire/ TiO₂ /PVA-H₃PO₄/CNT	2.07	2.73	75.70	[45]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/MWCNT/Separator/MWCNT/PVA-H₃PO₄/MWCNT	1.83	6.47	28.30	[11]
	Ti Fiber@TiO₂@dye/ I^-/I₃^-/Stainless steel(ss)@PANi-SS@Space wire/H₂SO₄/ss@PANi	2.12	4.56	46.00	[18]
	Ti/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Carbon fiber(CF)/EVA/Cu-CF@RuO₂?xH₂O/H₃PO₄/PVA/CF@RuO₂?xH₂O/EVA/Cu/PDMS	-	5.64	-	[46]
QDSSC-SPC	Glass/FTO/TiO₂@CdS/CdSe/S^2-/S/Cfiber@Cu₂S/C/Electrolyte/C		1.8		[48]
DSSC-LIB	Pt/Electrolyte/TNTs@N719/Ti/TNTs/Membrane/LiCoO₂/Al	0.82	-	-	[49]
	PEN/ITO/TiO₂@N719/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/PEDOT/LiClO₄/PEDOT/Pt	-	4.37	-	[50]
	FTO/TiO₂@N3/I^-/I₃^-/Pt/PProDOT-Et₂/LiClO₄/PProDOT-Et₂/Pt	0.60	0.75	80.00	[51]
	FTO/Pt/ I^-/I₃^-/TiO₂nanotube (ATO)@N749/Ti/ ATO/Separator/Li₂SO₄/ATO/Ti/FTO	1.64	3.18	51.60	[52]
	FTO/TiO₂@bis-EDOT dye/PEDOT/C/LiClO₄/electrolyte/ppy/FTO	0.10	-	-	[53]

Device construction	η_overall*/%	η_solar*/%	η_storage*/%	Ref.
FTO/c-TiO₂/m-TiO₂/CH₃NH₃PbI₃/Carbon/Gel electrolyte/Carbon	7.10	9.60	73.96	[72]
FTO/TiO₂/Perovskite/Carbon/MnO₂/Membrane SSE/Carbon	5.26	7.79	67.50	[13]
ITO/pss/PTAA/Perovskite/PCBM/PEI/Ag/GRO/PVA/Separator/PVA/GRO	10.97	13.66	80.31	[73]
FTO/TiO₂/CH₃NH₃PbI₃/MWCNT/PMMA/PVA/PANI@acSACNT/PMMA/SACNT	1.92	2.71	70.90	[74]
PET/ITO/PEDOT:PSS/CH₃NH₃PbI₃/PCBM/CuOHNT/AgNW/AuPd/MnO₂/KOH/PVA/MnO₂/AuPd/AgNW/CuOHNT	6.97	10.41	67.00	[75]